By any honest reckoning, Christianity in the public square is in crisis—not because the gospel has lost its power, but because it is so often conscripted into battles it was never meant to fight. On one side, far-right movements cloak agendas of hate, racism, antisemitism, and misogyny in Christian language, symbols, and selective proof texts. On the other hand, progressive or liberal movements appeal to Scripture’s themes of love, justice, and inclusion while using them to bless behaviors and moral frameworks that historic Christianity has consistently called disordered or ungodly. In both cases, Scripture is not being obeyed so much as exploited.